
On November 11 the European Commission published the Digital Fairness Act. Buried in the text is a rule that would end a decade of business-as-usual: selling paid loot boxes, pay-to-win or pay-to-progress mechanics to anyone under 18 becomes illegal.
What the Digital Fairness Act actually bans
Articles 14 through 16 carry the weight. Article 14 requires that whenever a player spends virtual currency, the trader shows what that spending is worth in real money. Article 15 covers "uncertainty-based rewards" — loot boxes, wheels of fortune, card packs. Odds and possible items must be disclosed, minors cannot be offered them at all, and every adult consumer must get an easily accessible switch to turn them off.
Article 16 is the one that reshapes monetisation: pay-to-win and pay-to-progress are prohibited for minors. The recitals define those broadly — artificial difficulty barriers, progression speeds that make the unpaid path illusory, and competitive structures where outcomes are effectively decided by spending.
Article 17 adds that all consumers, adults included, must be able to disable features designed to encourage compulsive or excessive use. The Commission reserves the right to expand that list through delegated acts.
There is also a definitional trap. Any game rated below PEGI 18 counts as "directed at minors." Felix Falk, managing director of Germany's game association, argues this makes PEGI and the German USK ratings meaningless, because every title under 18 would automatically be treated as a children's product.
Why the industry reacted this hard
The joint statement from the European Games Developer Federation and Video Games Europe landed the same day, headlined "The DFA is game over for the European games industry." Their argument is not that games need no rules; it is that the rules already exist. PEGI operates in 40 countries, and this year expanded its criteria to cover in-game purchases and paid random items.
Supercell CEO Ilkka Paananen put it bluntly on LinkedIn: "The proposal promises to protect European consumers. I believe it would hurt them." Roughly 95% of Supercell's monthly players never pay, so tightening the screws on the paying minority shrinks the free game everyone else is playing. He also attacked the price-display requirement directly:
Players buy currency at different prices, through bundles and offers, so any euro figure is a guess. That is confusion, not clarity.
King president Todd Green was softer but aligned: parts of the proposal "add further uncertainty rather than resolving it."
Three details that decide the outcome
Every currency spend becomes a "purchase"
The trade bodies single this out. Treating each in-game exchange as a purchase hardens the CPC Network's Key Principles on virtual currencies into law, which means 27 national interpretations, more litigation, and — in their words — games potentially becoming unplayable. For a live-service title this is not a copy problem. It is accounting, payments, refunds and regional compliance rebuilt at once.
The child threshold jumps to 18
Under the parallel Kids Act, social media restrictions stop at 15 and parents can lift them. The DFA applies a flat 18 to games with no parental override, which Falk calls patronising to both parents and teenagers. It also creates a perverse incentive: games rated 18 are largely exempt, so publishers may push for higher ratings — leaving teenagers with fewer games, not more.
6% of global turnover, against a rule nobody can define
A company earning €1 billion faces a theoretical €600 million penalty. Meanwhile pay-to-progress still has no operational test, and the Commission can extend the banned list later. Compliance cost that cannot be calculated is worse than compliance cost that is merely high.
The casualties won't be Tencent or Sony
The German association counts roughly 8,700 games companies in Europe; Video Games Europe cites 6,600. The scopes differ, the conclusion doesn't: most are small studios.
In-game spending is not a niche. Germany's association reports about €4.1 billion in in-game revenue in 2025 against roughly €800 million from game sales — a five-to-one ratio. Free-to-play economics rest on that.
Oscar Clark of Arcanix.AI told PocketGamer.biz: "Again, we will see the biggest impact on the smallest teams." A 20-person studio has no legal team to test where pay-to-progress begins and no engineering budget to build a global loot-box kill switch.
The industry's own failures are part of this
It would be lazy to frame this as Brussels versus game developers. Clark said the sharper thing himself: the industry's failure to police bad actors, and its failure to make its case, is "the price of those compounding failures."
He is right. Opaque odds, timed bundles engineered to create anxiety, teenagers spending four figures with no refund path — piled up over a decade, that record invites regulation. The alternative the industry proposed is not unreasonable: purchases off by default for children with parental unlock, real-money prices, refunds for unused currency, smaller top-ups. It simply arrived late and never made it into the text.
My take: right direction, wrong draft
Two clauses here are close to unarguable. Loot-box odds should be public. Children should not hit a paywall to progress.
But bundling that with "every exchange is a purchase," "under 18 means child," and "the Commission defines the rest later," then attaching a 6% penalty, changes the character of the thing. It is not drawing a line. It is taking the pen.
The proposal still has to survive the European Parliament and the Council, and public feedback runs to January 14, 2027. For studios outside Europe, the useful move is not waiting. Three checks now: can paid currency be switched off by account age in your EU build; does your odds page live at its own crawlable URL; does your refund policy state what happens to unused currency. Those three hold up regardless of the final text. We will keep tracking the amendments in GameHub's EU compliance section.
FAQ
Is the Digital Fairness Act in force yet?
No. November 11 was only the Commission's proposal. It now goes to the European Parliament and Council, with public feedback open until January 14, 2027, and the text can still change substantially.
Which games are hit hardest?
Any title rated below PEGI 18 is treated as directed at minors, so games with loot boxes or pay-to-win are most exposed. Most of Europe's roughly 8,700 games companies are small studios.
Can adults still buy loot boxes?
Yes. For adults the requirement is an accessible off switch plus disclosed odds and real-money value. The outright ban applies to under-18s.
What should studios do right now?
Three things: make paid currency switchable by account age, host loot-box odds on a standalone crawlable page, and write an explicit rule for unused virtual currency. More coverage at gghubs.com.